The concept of representation is a rich brocade whose complex weave is not fully appreciated. In the concept of representation, hanna pitkin 1967 argues that legislators should be judged by their actionssubstantive representation and not just their closeness in characteristics to. Pitkin offers one of the most comprehensive discussions of the concept of political representation, attending to its contradictory character in her the concept of representation. The starting place for much of this discussion is hanna pitkins seminal the concept of representation. Pdf hanna pitkins concept of representation revisited.
Only in the english civil war and then in the eighteenth. Pitkin s seminal work, the concept of representation 1967. Hanna pitkins 1967 seminal treatment identifies four distinct, but interconnected meanings or dimensions of representation including. Buy the concept of representation new ed by pitkin, hanna f. Aug, 2004 democracy came from ancient greece and was won through struggle, from below. She has shed light on such diverse topics as democracy, justice, gender, action, and. Political representation, democratic legitimacy, and institutional design. Being concerned with representation, this book is about an idea, a concept, a word. Gender and politics in the thought of machiavelli 1984, and the attack of the blob. The starting place for much of this discussion is hanna pitkin s seminal the concept of representation. An integrated model of womens representation leslie a.
It is an analysis both temptingly plausible and, as i hope to show, peculiarly wrong. The concept of representation by pitkin, hanna fenichel and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at. The picture of representation that results is not so much. This book arises out of hannah pitkin s doctoral dissertation and is considered by political scientists to be the gold standard in terms of a philosophical treatment of the. Schwindtbayer university of mississippi william mishler university of arizona the concept of representation, as developed in hanna pitkin s seminal work, is a complex structure. Hanna pitkins concept of representation revisited introduction article pdf available in politics and gender 84. Hanna fenichel pitkin 1998 university of chicago press. The conceptions of representation and their implications for strategies concerning the. She identifies four types of representation, but contends that three of theseformalistic, descriptive, and symbolic are limited. Pdf the concept of representation download full pdf book. The concept of representation download ebook pdf, epub.
Pitkin, the concept of representation, berkeleylos. In particular, her agonistic conception of representation highlights the importance of disagreements and rhetoric to the procedures, practices, and ethos of democracy. Should blacks represent blacks and women represen 63t women. The chicago distribution center has reopened and is fulfilling orders. Hanna fenichel pitkin 1974 philosophy and rhetoric 7 2. Concepts and correlates of political representation. An interview with hanna pitkin took place at the university of california, berkeley, in the spring of 2014. Hanna pitkin 1967 provides, perhaps, one of the most straightforward definitions.
This classic discussion of the concept of representation is one of the most influential and oftcited works in the literature on political representation. Pitkins seminal work, the concept of representation 1967. Click download or read online button to get the concept of representation book now. Download pdf hanna fenichel pitkin free online new. The concept of representation is a rich brocade whose complex weave is not always appreciated. Hanna pitkin s 1967 seminal treatment identifies four dis tinct, but interconnected meanings or dimensions of representation including. Being concerned with representation, this book is about. The concept of representation, as developed in hanna pitkin s seminal work, is a complex structure, whose multiple dimensions are hypothesized to be closely interconnected. Hence pitkin proposes a substantive view of representation.
Reviewed in the united states on february 11, 2008. Concept of representation by pitkin and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at. This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want. Most empirical work, however, ignores the integrated character of representation and examines its several dimensions in isolation. Scribd is the worlds largest social reading and publishing site. Hanna fenichel pitkin wurde 1931 als tochter des psychoanalytikers otto fenichel in berlin geboren. Daughter of otto fenichel, pitkin was born in berlin and emigrated to the united states in 1938. These are descriptive, substantive, formalistic and symbolic representation. Instead, i argue, it would be more useful to develop the various concepts that emphasize the underlying forms of representation.
The most influential was hanna pitkins in the concept of representation published in 1967. I argue that our main disagreements are conceptual, and are trace able to the attempt to treat the concept of representation as a single highly complex concept as hanna pitkin once put it. Hanna pitkin s the concept of representation haskell fain unwersriy of wisconsin, madison i the concept of representation has traditionally been more carefully scrutinized by political theorists than by political philosophers. Pitkin argues that these views of political representation give an inadequate account of political representation because they lack an account both of how representatives act for the represented and the normative criteria for judging representatives actions. Jacqueline anne sullivan 2010 philosophy of science supplement 77 5. In the concept of representation, hanna pitkin 1967 argues that legislators should be judged by their actionssubstantive representation and not just their closeness in characteristics to their constituentsdescriptive representation. Pdf the concept of representation semantic scholar. The concepts of representation andrew rehfeld washington university in st. Hanna pitkin 1967, in her influential book the concept of representation, identifies. Pitkin, hanna 1931 bibliography hanna fenichel pitkin is one of the most influential political theorists of the twentieth century. I argue that our main disagreements are conceptual, and are trace. Hanna fenichel pitkin download ebook pdf, epub, tuebl, mobi.
No one would argue that morons should be represented by morons. The concepts of representation department of political. John stuart mill is an exception 3, but his thoughts on representative government have. Download pdf the concept of representation book full free. This book arises out of hannah pitkin s doctoral dissertation and is considered by political scientists to be the gold standard in terms of a philosophical treatment of the subject. Pdf the concept of representation download full pdf. A role for representation in cognitive neurobiology. Hobbess concept of representationi american political. Representation dates at least as a political concept and practice from the late medieval period, when it was imposed as a duty by the monarch. This handbook is currently in development, with individual articles publishing online in advance of print publication. The concepts of representation political science at. The concept of representation by hanna fenichel pitkin, 9780520021563, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide.
But the fact is that representation plays a central role in the leviathan. On the significance of ludwig wittgenstein for social and political thought. Pitkins theoretical framework is the standard that political representation scholars use when. There is likely to be much debate about the advantages and disadvantages of adopting representative institutions. Political representation stanford encyclopedia of philosophy.
Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Pitkin is the author of books well known to scholars and students in political theory and political science. The most influential was hanna pitkin s in the concept of representation published in 1967. Greek democracy was participatory and bore no relationship to representation. Oxford handbook of classics in contemporary political. In her view, substantive representationwhat she often refers to as acting for representationis the one true type. Other readers will always be interested in your opinion of the books youve read. Should blacks represent blacks and women represent women.
This criticism rests o primariln confusin twgy formo s of descriptiv repe resentation, the microcosmic and the selective forms. We first clarify our position with respect to pitkin, and draw up the borders of symbolic representation, a concept that is at the same time broad and understudied by scholars in gender and politics, and in politics more broadly speaking. Hanna pitkin argues that wittgensteins later philosophy offers a revolutionary new conception of language, and hence a new and deeper understanding of ourselves and the world of human institutions and action. On this definition, political representation is the activity of making citizens voices, opinions, and perspectives present in public policy making processes. Whether youve loved the book or not, if you give your honest and detailed thoughts then people will find new books that are right for them. In the concept of representation, hanna pitkin 1967 argues that legislators should be judged by their actionssubstantive representationand not just their closeness in characteristics to their constituentsdescriptive representation. Hanna pitkin, the concept of representation oxford handbooks. Hannah arendts concept of the social, hanna fenichel pitkin is published by university of chicago press. The concept of representation available for download and read online in other formats. She is a professor emerita of political science at the university of california, berkeley. Rather than formulating these debates in terms of one concept of representation, let alone the concept of representation, as pitkin put it, i believe it would be more use. Feminist engagement with the concept of representation dates back more than ten years. Click download or read online button to get hanna fenichel pitkin book now. Pitkin, the concept of representation, berkeleylos angeles 1967.
Using ludwig wittgensteins ordinarylanguage theory, pitkin explores the semantic landscape and the etymology of the concept of representation. In the concept of representa tion, hanna pitkin 1967 argues that legislators should be judged by their actions substantive representation and not just their closeness in characteristics. Pitkin the concept of representation 1972 free ebook download as pdf file. Pitkins books are the concept of representation 1967, wittgenstein and justice 1972, 1984, 1992, and fortune is a woman. Hanna pitkin the concept of representation hanna fenichel. In her view, substantive representation what she often refers to as acting for representation is the one true type. An integrated model of womens representation the journal. The concept of representation by hanna fenichel pitkin. It is primarily a conceptual analysis, not a historical study of the way in which representative government has evolved, nor yet an empirical investigation of the behavior of contemporary representatives or the expectations voters have about them.
Pitkin, the concept of representation, berkeleylos angeles 1967 springerlink. While best known for her seminal book the concept of representation 1967, pitkin has composed several works of lasting relevance to the study of politics. Hanna pitkins the concept of representation haskell fain unwersriy of wisconsin, madison i the concept of representation has traditionally been more carefully scrutinized by political theorists than by political philosophers. Pitkin s theoretical framework is the standard that political representation scholars use when. The concept of representation hanna pitkin download. Gender,race,ethnicity,andpoliticalrepresentationinthe. All chicago ebooks are on sale at 30% off with the code ebook30. The concept of representation 1967, wittgenstein and justice 1972, fortune is a woman. Hanna fenichel pitkin born july 17, 1931 is a political theorist. Gender and politics in the thought of niccolo machiavelli 1984, 1999, in addition to numerous articles and edited volumes.
540 608 540 558 1184 1221 1429 458 1254 1180 548 743 402 1484 1060 1514 472 1124 272 1518 1459 1367 233 142 56 1368 535 1225 707 1501 1047 793 70 599 292 947 419 669 380